Rider Athletics Hall of Fame
Umbehauer placed third in the nation to earn All-America honors as a senior in 2009. He finished with a career record of 100-35 as a four-time NCAA qualifier and came within one win of All-America honors as a junior. A two-time CAA Champion and a two-time CAA runner-up, he was 24-5 as a senior and was the seventh seed at 2009 Nationals, where he defeated the second seed twice, including the battle to finish third. Umbehauer won 27 matches as a junior and 28 as a sophomore. He placed runner-up at Midlands before his junior season and was a Freshman All-American in 2006.