Skip To Main Content
Skip To Main Content

Rider University Athletics

Rider Broncs
The Official Website of Rider University Athletics

# Rider (1-6,0-0 MAAC) -VS- # Villanova (7-2,0-0 Big East)

Box Score

Rider logo
0
vs
Villanova logo
3

# Rider (1-6,0-0 MAAC)
-VS-
# Villanova (7-2,0-0 Big East)

Team Score By Period
Team 1 2 3
Rider Rider 24 20 18
Winner Villanova VU 26 25 25
Date:
9/9/2023
Time:
3:05 pm
Site:
Newark, DE (Bob Carpenter Center)
Attendance:
0
VIEW
Match History vs Villanova

Match Details

Game Statistics By Set
Set Rider Villanova
K E TA % K E TA %
Set #1 9 4 29 0.172 10 4 29 0.207
Set #2 10 7 32 0.094 12 5 30 0.233
Set #3 11 10 37 0.027 10 4 35 0.171
Total 30 21 98 .092 32 13 94 .202
Team Statistical Comparison
Statistic Team Comparison
Rider - VU
Points
41.0
48.0
Kills
30
32
Aces
6
8
Blocks
5
8
Assists
27
30
Digs
35
35

Game Leaders

Rider - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Giehtbrock, Paige (16), Rohde, Molly (4), Robinson, Rylah (3)
Aces O'Connor, Keegan (2), Zimmet, Carly (2), Santiago, Kiannisha (1)
Blocks Rohde, Molly (5), Johnson, Brynn (1), Kelly, Anja (1)
Assists Mason, Makenna (12), Frye, Ryley (11), O'Connor, Keegan (1)
Digs O'Connor, Keegan (7), Mason, Makenna (6), Giehtbrock, Paige (5)
VU - Leaders
Statistic Leaders
Kills Harrell, Abby (9), Barber, Madeline (7), Booth, Kiera (6)
Aces Whittingham, Taryn (2), Campos, Andrea (2), Ortiz, Dani (2)
Blocks Homer, Riley (4), Booth, Kiera (4), Barber, Madeline (2)
Assists Campos, Andrea (24), Feczko, Elizabeth (4), Gray, Ellery (1)
Digs Feczko, Elizabeth (11), Campos, Andrea (8), Harrell, Abby (6)

Individual Statistics

Rider (1-6,0-0 MAAC)

Rider - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
2 2 O'Connor, Keegan 3 0 0 1 .000 1 0 2 3 2-3 0 0 0 7 0 0 2.0
4 4 Johnson, Brynn 3 2 3 11 -.091 0 1 0 0 0-0 0 1 0 3 0 0 2.5
14 14 Giehtbrock, Paige 3 16 9 40 .175 0 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 5 0 1 16.0
17 17 Langford, Simone 3 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 1-1 0 0 0 4 0 0 1.0
6 6 Rohde, Molly 3 4 2 14 .143 0 0 0 0 0-0 2 3 0 1 0 0 7.5
3 3 Strah, Molly 2 1 0 1 1.000 0 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 3 0 2 1.0
0 0 Frye, Ryley 2 0 0 3 .000 11 1 0 2 0-2 0 0 0 2 0 0 0.0
12 12 McAleavey, Carley 2 1 1 5 .000 1 1 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1.0
9 9 Mason, Makenna 2 0 0 2 .000 12 0 0 1 0-1 0 0 0 6 0 0 0.0
7 7 Robinson, Rylah 2 3 2 11 .091 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 1 0 0 0 0 3.5
13 13 Zimmet, Carly 2 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 0 2-0 0 0 0 2 0 1 2.0
11 11 Santiago, Kiannisha 1 1 0 4 .250 0 0 1 2 1-2 0 0 0 2 0 0 2.0
22 22 Kelly, Anja 1 2 2 4 .000 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 1 0 0 0 0 2.5
1 1 Mattingly, Mia 1 0 2 2 -1.000 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0
Totals 30 21 98 .092 27 4 6 11 6-11 2 6 0 35 0 8 41
Rider - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
2 2 O'Connor, Keegan 3 0 0 0 7 0 0 2.0
4 4 Johnson, Brynn 3 0 1 0 3 0 0 2.5
14 14 Giehtbrock, Paige 3 0 0 0 5 0 1 16.0
17 17 Langford, Simone 3 0 0 0 4 0 0 1.0
6 6 Rohde, Molly 3 2 3 0 1 0 0 7.5
3 3 Strah, Molly 2 0 0 0 3 0 2 1.0
0 0 Frye, Ryley 2 0 0 0 2 0 0 0.0
12 12 McAleavey, Carley 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 1.0
9 9 Mason, Makenna 2 0 0 0 6 0 0 0.0
7 7 Robinson, Rylah 2 0 1 0 0 0 0 3.5
13 13 Zimmet, Carly 2 0 0 0 2 0 1 2.0
11 11 Santiago, Kiannisha 1 0 0 0 2 0 0 2.0
22 22 Kelly, Anja 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 2.5
1 1 Mattingly, Mia 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0
Totals 2 6 0 35 0 8 41

Villanova (7-2,0-0 Big East)

VU - Individual
# Player SP Attack Set Serve Block Def Rec
K E TA Pct A E SA SE SA-SE BS BA BE DIG BHE RE Pts
4 4 Barber, Madeline 3 7 0 12 .583 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 2 0 2 0 0 8.0
6 6 Homer, Riley 3 3 1 11 .182 0 0 0 0 0-0 1 3 0 1 0 0 5.5
9 9 Whittingham, Taryn 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 2-0 0 0 0 3 0 0 2.0
11 11 Campos, Andrea 3 2 0 6 .333 24 0 2 3 2-3 1 0 0 8 0 0 5.0
23 23 Booth, Kiera 3 6 3 13 .231 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 4 0 0 0 0 8.0
1 1 Feczko, Elizabeth 3 0 0 1 .000 4 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 11 0 3 0.0
15 15 Ortiz, Dani 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 3 2-3 0 0 0 1 0 0 2.0
12 12 Gerhardt, Skylar 3 5 4 26 .038 1 0 1 3 1-3 0 1 0 3 0 2 6.5
10 10 Harrell, Abby 3 9 5 24 .167 0 1 1 3 1-3 0 2 0 6 0 0 11.0
22 22 Diamond, Angelle 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
2 2 Gray, Ellery 1 0 0 1 .000 1 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0-0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0
Totals 32 13 94 .202 30 1 8 12 8-12 2 12 0 35 0 6 48
VU - Individual
# Player SP Block Def Rec Pts
BS BA BE DIG BHE RE
4 4 Barber, Madeline 3 0 2 0 2 0 0 8.0
6 6 Homer, Riley 3 1 3 0 1 0 0 5.5
9 9 Whittingham, Taryn 3 0 0 0 3 0 0 2.0
11 11 Campos, Andrea 3 1 0 0 8 0 0 5.0
23 23 Booth, Kiera 3 0 4 0 0 0 0 8.0
1 1 Feczko, Elizabeth 3 0 0 0 11 0 3 0.0
15 15 Ortiz, Dani 3 0 0 0 1 0 0 2.0
12 12 Gerhardt, Skylar 3 0 1 0 3 0 2 6.5
10 10 Harrell, Abby 3 0 2 0 6 0 0 11.0
22 22 Diamond, Angelle 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
2 2 Gray, Ellery 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0
TM TM TEAM 3 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0
Totals 2 12 0 35 0 6 48

Play By Play

Set #1 Plays

Set #1 Plays
Serve Team Rider - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score VU - Play Description
VU [Whittingham, Taryn] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Frye, Ryley). 1 Villanova 0
Rider 1 Rider 1 [Giehtbrock, Paige] Kill by Booth, Kiera.
VU [Gerhardt, Skylar] Attack error by Harrell, Abby (block by Rohde, Molly; Johnson, Brynn). 2 Villanova 1
Rider 2 Rider 2 [O'Connor, Keegan] Service error.
-- VU subs: Ortiz, Dani.
VU [Ortiz, Dani] Service error. 3 Villanova 2
-- Rider subs: Langford, Simone.
Rider 3 Rider 3 [Langford, Simone] Attack error by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Frye, Ryley).
-- VU subs: Homer, Riley.
VU [Campos, Andrea] Service error. 4 Villanova 3
Rider [Santiago, Kiannisha] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Frye, Ryley). 5 Villanova 3
Rider [Santiago, Kiannisha] Service ace (Feczko, Elizabeth). 6 Villanova 3
Rider 6 Rider 4 [Santiago, Kiannisha] Service error.
-- Rider subs: Strah, Molly.
VU [Harrell, Abby] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Frye, Ryley). 7 Villanova 4
Rider 7 Rider 5 [McAleavey, Carley] Bad set by McAleavey, Carley.
VU [Feczko, Elizabeth] Kill by Rohde, Molly (from Langford, Simone). 8 Villanova 5
Rider 8 Rider 6 [Frye, Ryley] Service error.
VU 8 Rider 7 [Whittingham, Taryn] Service ace (Strah, Molly).
VU 8 Rider 8 [Whittingham, Taryn] Kill by Gerhardt, Skylar (from Feczko, Elizabeth).
VU [Whittingham, Taryn] Bad set by Harrell, Abby. 9 Villanova 8
Rider [Giehtbrock, Paige] Kill by Johnson, Brynn (from Frye, Ryley). 10 Villanova 8
Rider [Giehtbrock, Paige] Attack error by Gerhardt, Skylar (from Campos, Andrea). 11 Villanova 8
Rider 11 Rider 9 [Giehtbrock, Paige] Kill by Campos, Andrea.
VU [Gerhardt, Skylar] Kill by Rohde, Molly (from Frye, Ryley). 12 Villanova 9
Rider 12 Rider 10 [O'Connor, Keegan] Service error.
VU 12 Rider 11 [Ortiz, Dani] Service ace (Giehtbrock, Paige).
VU [Ortiz, Dani] Service error. 13 Villanova 11
Rider [Langford, Simone] Attack error by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea). 14 Villanova 11
Rider 14 Rider 12 [Langford, Simone] Kill by Barber, Madeline (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 14 Rider 13 [Campos, Andrea] Kill by Harrell, Abby (from Gerhardt, Skylar).
VU [Campos, Andrea] Service error. 15 Villanova 13
Rider 15 Rider 14 [Santiago, Kiannisha] Service error.
VU 15 Rider 15 [Harrell, Abby] Attack error by Giehtbrock, Paige (block by Homer, Riley; Barber, Madeline).
VU 15 Rider 16 [Harrell, Abby] Service ace (Team).
VU [Harrell, Abby] Service error. 16 Villanova 16
-- Rider subs: Zimmet, Carly.
Rider [Zimmet, Carly] Service ace (Gerhardt, Skylar). 17 Villanova 16
Rider [Zimmet, Carly] Service ace (Gerhardt, Skylar). 18 Villanova 16
Rider 18 Rider 17 [Zimmet, Carly] Kill by Barber, Madeline (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Feczko, Elizabeth] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Frye, Ryley). 19 Villanova 17
Rider 19 Rider 18 [Frye, Ryley] Service error.
VU 19 Rider 19 [Whittingham, Taryn] Attack error by Rohde, Molly (block by Booth, Kiera; Gerhardt, Skylar).
VU [Whittingham, Taryn] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Frye, Ryley). 20 Villanova 19
Rider 20 Rider 20 [Giehtbrock, Paige] Service error.
VU 20 Rider 21 [Gerhardt, Skylar] Attack error by Giehtbrock, Paige.
VU [Gerhardt, Skylar] Service error. 21 Villanova 21
Rider [O'Connor, Keegan] Attack error by Booth, Kiera (from Campos, Andrea). 22 Villanova 21
Rider 22 Rider 22 [O'Connor, Keegan] Kill by Booth, Kiera (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 22 Rider 23 [Ortiz, Dani] Kill by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 22 Rider 24 [Ortiz, Dani] Kill by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Ortiz, Dani] Kill by Santiago, Kiannisha (from Frye, Ryley). 23 Villanova 24
Rider [Langford, Simone] Service ace (Team). 24 Villanova 24
Rider 24 Rider 25 [Langford, Simone] Service error.
VU 24 Rider 26 [Campos, Andrea] Kill by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea).

Set #2 Plays

Set #2 Plays
Serve Team Rider - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score VU - Play Description
-- VU subs: Homer, Riley.
-- VU subs: Booth, Kiera.
-- Rider subs: Strah, Molly; Santiago, Kiannisha; Zimmet, Carly; Langford, Simone; Robinson, Rylah.
Rider [Frye, Ryley] Attack error by Gerhardt, Skylar (block by Rohde, Molly). 1 Villanova 0
Rider [Frye, Ryley] Attack error by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea). 2 Villanova 0
Rider 2 Rider 1 [Frye, Ryley] Kill by Barber, Madeline (from Campos, Andrea).
-- VU subs: Homer, Riley.
VU 2 Rider 2 [Campos, Andrea] Service ace (Team).
VU 2 Rider 3 [Campos, Andrea] Attack error by Johnson, Brynn (block by Harrell, Abby; Barber, Madeline).
VU [Campos, Andrea] Attack error by Gerhardt, Skylar (block by Rohde, Molly). 3 Villanova 3
Rider 3 Rider 4 [Giehtbrock, Paige] Kill by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Harrell, Abby] Kill by Rohde, Molly (from Frye, Ryley). 4 Villanova 4
Rider 4 Rider 5 [O'Connor, Keegan] Kill by Gerhardt, Skylar (from Campos, Andrea).
-- VU subs: Booth, Kiera.
VU 4 Rider 6 [Feczko, Elizabeth] Attack error by McAleavey, Carley (block by Homer, Riley; Booth, Kiera).
VU 4 Rider 7 [Feczko, Elizabeth] Attack error by Robinson, Rylah (block by Homer, Riley; Booth, Kiera).
VU 4 Rider 8 [Feczko, Elizabeth] Bad set by Frye, Ryley.
VU [Feczko, Elizabeth] Kill by Robinson, Rylah (from Frye, Ryley). 5 Villanova 8
-- Rider subs: Langford, Simone.
Rider 5 Rider 9 [Langford, Simone] Kill by Homer, Riley (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Whittingham, Taryn] Attack error by Booth, Kiera (from Campos, Andrea). 6 Villanova 9
-- Rider subs: Strah, Molly.
Rider [Strah, Molly] Attack error by Booth, Kiera (from Campos, Andrea). 7 Villanova 9
Rider 7 Rider 10 [Strah, Molly] Service error.
VU 7 Rider 11 [Gerhardt, Skylar] Service ace (Strah, Molly).
VU [Gerhardt, Skylar] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Langford, Simone). 8 Villanova 11
Rider 8 Rider 12 [McAleavey, Carley] Kill by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Ortiz, Dani] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Frye, Ryley). 9 Villanova 12
Rider 9 Rider 13 [Frye, Ryley] Kill by Barber, Madeline (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 9 Rider 14 [Campos, Andrea] Kill by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 9 Rider 15 [Campos, Andrea] Attack error by Giehtbrock, Paige (from O'Connor, Keegan).
VU 9 Rider 16 [Campos, Andrea] Kill by Homer, Riley (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 9 Rider 17 [Campos, Andrea] Attack error by Giehtbrock, Paige (block by Homer, Riley).
-- Rider subs: Mason, Makenna.
VU 9 Rider 18 [Campos, Andrea] Service ace (Team).
VU [Campos, Andrea] Kill by Strah, Molly (from Mason, Makenna). 10 Villanova 18
Rider 10 Rider 19 [Giehtbrock, Paige] Kill by Gerhardt, Skylar (from Feczko, Elizabeth).
VU [Harrell, Abby] Service error. 11 Villanova 19
Rider [O'Connor, Keegan] Service ace (Feczko, Elizabeth). 12 Villanova 19
Rider [O'Connor, Keegan] Kill by Robinson, Rylah (from Mason, Makenna). 13 Villanova 19
Rider [O'Connor, Keegan] Service ace (Feczko, Elizabeth). 14 Villanova 19
Rider 14 Rider 20 [O'Connor, Keegan] Kill by Homer, Riley (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 14 Rider 21 [Feczko, Elizabeth] Attack error by Johnson, Brynn (from Mason, Makenna).
VU [Feczko, Elizabeth] Kill by McAleavey, Carley (from Mason, Makenna). 15 Villanova 21
Rider 15 Rider 22 [Langford, Simone] Kill by Booth, Kiera (from Campos, Andrea).
-- VU subs: Gray, Ellery.
VU [Whittingham, Taryn] Kill by Robinson, Rylah (from Mason, Makenna). 16 Villanova 22
Rider [Strah, Molly] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Mason, Makenna). 17 Villanova 22
Rider [Strah, Molly] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from McAleavey, Carley). 18 Villanova 22
Rider 18 Rider 23 [Strah, Molly] Attack error by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Langford, Simone).
VU [Gerhardt, Skylar] Service error. 19 Villanova 23
Rider 19 Rider 24 [McAleavey, Carley] Kill by Booth, Kiera (from Gray, Ellery).
VU [Ortiz, Dani] Service error. 20 Villanova 24
Rider 20 Rider 25 [Mason, Makenna] Service error.

Set #3 Plays

Set #3 Plays
Serve Team Rider - Play Description Visiting Team Score Scoring Team Logo Home Team Score VU - Play Description
-- VU subs: Gray, Ellery; Homer, Riley; Ortiz, Dani.
-- Rider subs: Frye, Ryley; Strah, Molly; McAleavey, Carley; Langford, Simone; Mattingly, Mia.
VU [Gerhardt, Skylar] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Mason, Makenna). 1 Villanova 0
Rider 1 Rider 1 [Giehtbrock, Paige] Attack error by Johnson, Brynn (block by Booth, Kiera; Harrell, Abby).
-- VU subs: Ortiz, Dani.
VU 1 Rider 2 [Ortiz, Dani] Service ace (Team).
VU 1 Rider 3 [Ortiz, Dani] Attack error by Mattingly, Mia (from Mason, Makenna).
VU 1 Rider 4 [Ortiz, Dani] Attack error by Robinson, Rylah (from Mason, Makenna).
VU [Ortiz, Dani] Kill by Johnson, Brynn. 2 Villanova 4
Rider 2 Rider 5 [O'Connor, Keegan] Bad set by Johnson, Brynn.
-- VU subs: Homer, Riley.
VU 2 Rider 6 [Campos, Andrea] Kill by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Campos, Andrea] Service error. 3 Villanova 6
-- Rider subs: Langford, Simone.
Rider [Langford, Simone] Attack error by Gerhardt, Skylar (from Campos, Andrea). 4 Villanova 6
Rider 4 Rider 7 [Langford, Simone] Kill by Barber, Madeline (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Harrell, Abby] Service error. 5 Villanova 7
-- Rider subs: Zimmet, Carly.
Rider [Zimmet, Carly] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from O'Connor, Keegan). 6 Villanova 7
Rider 6 Rider 8 [Zimmet, Carly] Kill by Barber, Madeline (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 6 Rider 9 [Feczko, Elizabeth] Attack error by Rohde, Molly (from Mason, Makenna).
VU 6 Rider 10 [Feczko, Elizabeth] Bad set by Zimmet, Carly.
VU [Feczko, Elizabeth] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Mason, Makenna). 7 Villanova 10
Rider 7 Rider 11 [Rohde, Molly] Kill by Gerhardt, Skylar (from Feczko, Elizabeth).
VU [Whittingham, Taryn] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Mason, Makenna). 8 Villanova 11
-- Rider subs: Kelly, Anja.
Rider [Mason, Makenna] Kill by Kelly, Anja (from Zimmet, Carly). 9 Villanova 11
Rider 9 Rider 12 [Mason, Makenna] Kill by Booth, Kiera (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 9 Rider 13 [Gerhardt, Skylar] Attack error by Kelly, Anja (from Giehtbrock, Paige).
VU [Gerhardt, Skylar] Service error. 10 Villanova 13
Rider 10 Rider 14 [Giehtbrock, Paige] Kill by Harrell, Abby (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Ortiz, Dani] Kill by Kelly, Anja (from Mason, Makenna). 11 Villanova 14
Rider 11 Rider 15 [O'Connor, Keegan] Service error.
VU [Campos, Andrea] Attack error by Harrell, Abby (block by Rohde, Molly; Kelly, Anja). 12 Villanova 15
Rider [Langford, Simone] Attack error by Harrell, Abby (block by Robinson, Rylah; Rohde, Molly). 13 Villanova 15
Rider 13 Rider 16 [Langford, Simone] Kill by Barber, Madeline (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Harrell, Abby] Kill by Rohde, Molly (from Mason, Makenna). 14 Villanova 16
Rider [Zimmet, Carly] Attack error by Homer, Riley (from Campos, Andrea). 15 Villanova 16
Rider [Zimmet, Carly] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Mason, Makenna). 16 Villanova 16
Rider 16 Rider 17 [Zimmet, Carly] Kill by Gerhardt, Skylar (from Campos, Andrea).
VU 16 Rider 18 [Feczko, Elizabeth] Kill by Booth, Kiera (from Campos, Andrea).
VU [Feczko, Elizabeth] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Zimmet, Carly). 17 Villanova 18
Rider 17 Rider 19 [Rohde, Molly] Kill by Campos, Andrea (from Feczko, Elizabeth).
VU 17 Rider 20 [Whittingham, Taryn] Attack error by Giehtbrock, Paige (block by Campos, Andrea).
VU 17 Rider 21 [Whittingham, Taryn] Service ace (Zimmet, Carly).
VU 17 Rider 22 [Whittingham, Taryn] Attack error by Mattingly, Mia (from Mason, Makenna).
VU 17 Rider 23 [Whittingham, Taryn] Attack error by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Mason, Makenna).
-- VU subs: Diamond, Angelle.
VU [Whittingham, Taryn] Kill by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Mason, Makenna). 18 Villanova 23
Rider 18 Rider 24 [Mason, Makenna] Attack error by Kelly, Anja (from Mason, Makenna).
VU 18 Rider 25 [Gerhardt, Skylar] Attack error by Giehtbrock, Paige (from Mason, Makenna).